Markii aan kuwa kale kala hadalnay noocyada cusub ee Windows , annagoo aan dooneen ayaanu bilownay dood ku saabsan ribbon iyo waxtarkeeda. Dadka qaarkiis ayaan jeclayn in Windows 10 iyo Windows 8.1 ay si aad ah u isticmaalaan Windows 7 , waxaana jira dad weli ka cawda in ay aad uga wanagsan tahay marka loo eego interface-kii hore ee Windows XP . Si loo soo afjaro dooddan iyada oo la adeegsanayo xaqiiqooyin beddelka fikradaha shakhsi ahaaneed, waxaan go'aansannay inaan abuurno halbeegyo nooc ah. Qiyaaso taxane ah oo loo isticmaali karo in lagu barbar dhigo hufnaanta interface ribbon, sida loo isticmaalo Windows 10 vs. Windows 8.1 vs. Windows 7vs interface ka Windows XP hore . Waa kuwan natiijooyinka:

Habka baaritaanka

Waxaan abuurnay afar mashiin oo kala ah: mid leh Windows 10 , mid leh Windows 8.1 , mid leh Windows 7 , midna leh Windows XP Service Pack 3 . Dhammaan nidaamyada qalliinka waxa lagu rakibay dhammaan cusbooneysiintii ugu dambeysay. Waxaan tijaabinay seddex codsi oo ku jira dhammaan nidaamyadan hawlgalka, kuwaas oo dhammaantood adeegsada ribbon: WordPad , Rinjiga^(Paint) iyo Windows/File Explorer .

Dabadeed, waxaanu awoodnay dhammaan aaladaha iyo badhamada laga heli karo codsiyadan. Tusaale ahaan, waxaanu awoodnay dhammaan badhamada ku jira Qalabka Helitaanka Degdegga ah ee^{(Quick Access Toolbar)} laga helay abka Windows 10 , Windows 8.1 iyo Windows 7 . Windows XP , waxaanu awoodnay dhammaan aaladaha ku jira Windows Explorer . Dhammaan badhamadan iyo baararkan waxa la damiyay iyaddoo la isticmaalayo menu-yada caadiga ah iyo dejinta. Uma aynaan socodsiin^(NOT) wax jabsiga diiwaanka ama aaladaha qolo saddexaad si aan awood ugu siinno astaamo dheeri ah.

Kadib, waxaanu ku qornay waxa aanu u malaynayno inay yihiin hawlaha ugu badan ee laga yaabo inaad ku fuliso saddexdan codsi ( WordPad , Rinjiga^(Paint) iyo File Explorer ), gudaha Windows 10 , Windows 8.1, Windows 7 iyo Windows XP . Waxaan cabbirnay tirada tillaabooyinka loo baahan yahay si loo dhammaystiro hawlahaas, waxaanan barbar dhignay natiijooyinka. Hawl kasta oo aan lagu fulin karin dhammaan nidaamyada hawlgalka, ayaa laga saaray cabbirada. Tusaale ahaan, gudaha Windows XP , ma geli kartid URL ciwaanka degelka sida isku xirka xulashada qoraalka ee WordPad , Redo - na kama jiro sifo ahaan Windows Explorer .

Waxa aanu rabnay in aanu samayno isbarbardhig ku salaysan gujin si aanu u isticmaalin furaha kiiboodhka si aanu u dedejino mid ka mid ah hawlaha. Wax walba waxaa lagu sameeyay iyadoo la isticmaalayo jiirka, menu-yada, iyo badhamada laga heli karo codsi kasta. Kiiboodhka lama isticmaalin ilaa aan loo baahnayn in la sameeyo qoraal khasab ah si loo dhamaystiro hawsha (tusaale magaca beddelka faylka ama gal).

Isku xirka isticmaalaha ribbon ee WordPad - Ilaa 21% ka hufan

Codsigii ugu horreeyay ee aan falanqeynay wuxuu ahaa WordPad - tifaftiraha dukumeentiga caadiga ah ee lagu daray dhammaan noocyada iyo daabacadaha Windows .

Waxaanu taxnay 12 hawlood oo caadi ah oo ay dadku fuliyaan markay ku shaqaynayaan dukumeenti ku jira WordPad . In kasta oo natiijadu ay si la yaab leh ula mid tahay inta badan hawlaha lagu qabto Windows 10 , Windows 8.1 ama Windows 7 , arrimuhu si weyn ayay isu beddeleen marka loo eego Windows XP . " Koobi^(Copy) & paste gaar ah", gelida sawirada, iyo kaydinta dukumentiyada dhamaantood waa hawlo aad si dhakhso leh u qaban doonto haddii aad isticmaasho hababka casriga ah ee Windows .

Isku soo wada duuboo, waxaan aaminsanahay inay cadaalad tahay in la yiraahdo ribbon Windows 10 wuxuu keenayaa horumar hufnaan ilaa 21% marka la barbar dhigo Windows XP , laakiin waa 3% oo keliya ka dhakhso badan interface-ka ribbon ee Windows 8.1 . Shaxda soo socotaa waa inay ku siiso sawir cad.

Isku xirka isticmaalaha ribbon ee Rinjiga^(Paint) - Ilaa 42% ka hufan

Aan u tagno Rinjiyeynta^(Paint) - aaladda ay u badan tahay inuu noqdo barnaamijka rinjiyeynta garaafyada ugu aasaasiga ah ee dunida. Codsigan waxa aanu ku tijaabinay tiro ka kooban 16 hawlood.

Halkan, hagaajinta is-dhexgalka isticmaalaha ribbon uu keenay Windows 7 , Windows 8.1 iyo Windows 10 waa wax iska cad marka la barbardhigo Windows XP hore .

Waxaa la yaab leh, waxay sidoo kale u egtahay in aysan waxba iska beddelin tan iyo Windows 7 , sida natiijooyinka aan ku helnay cabbirada waxay ahaayeen kuwo isku mid ah noocyadii ugu dambeeyay ee Windows . Laakiin, waxaan rajaynaynaa, is-dhexgalka isticmaalaha ee Rinjiga^(Paint) wuxuu noqon doonaa mid aad waxtar u leh dhawaanaha soo socda Windows 10 Cusboonaysiinta Hal^{(Creators Update)} -abuurka .

Rinjiga^(Paint) , interface - ka ribbon waa ilaa 42% ka waxtar badan Windows 10 , Windows 8.1 iyo Windows 7 , marka loo eego menu-yadii hore ee loo isticmaali jiray Windows XP .

Isku xirka isticmaalaha ribbon ee Windows/File Explorer - Ilaa 55% ka hufan

Ugu dambeyntii, laakiin ugu yaraan, waxaan tijaabinay Windows/File Explorer , kaas oo ah codsiga ugu isticmaalka badan dhammaan saddexda aan eegnay.

Waxaanu is barbar dhignay tiro 15 hawlood ah oo aanu aaminsanahay in ay si qurux badan u fuliyaan dadka isticmaala qalabkan.

Gudaha Windows/File Explorer waxaan ku ogaanay horumarka ugu weyn ee aaladaha oo dhan. Faylka Explorer^{(File Explorer)} ee ku jira Windows 10 iyo Windows 8.1 ayaa 43% ka waxtar badan kan Windows XP . Ma aha oo kaliya in ribbonku si dhakhso ah u siyo isticmaalaha fursadaha kala duwan, laakiin sidoo kale waxaa ku jira doorashooyin cusub oo si fiican u habaysan nooc kasta oo cusub oo Windows ah. Si kastaba ha ahaatee, wax horumar ah kama helin File Explorer ka Windows 10 , marka la barbar dhigo File Explorer ee Windows 8.1 .

Gabagabo

Shakhsi ahaan, ma aanaan fileyn inaan aragno horumar weyn oo ku saabsan isticmaalka inta u dhaxaysa noocyada kala duwan ee is-dhexgalka ribbon. Laakiin, waxaan aaminsanahay in natiijadu ay u hadlaan naftooda. Ribbon-ka ku jira Windows 8.1 iyo Windows 10 waxa uu si dhakhso leh u gelayaa tallaabooyinka iyo kontaroolada laga heli karo codsi kasta oo aanu tijaabinay, marka la barbar dhigo is-dhexgalka isticmaale ee aad ka heli doonto Windows 7 . Dhanka kale, dadka isticmaala qaab-dhismeedka hore waxay inta badan habeeyaan menu-yada si dhammaan hawlaha caadiga ah loogu helo hal gujis. Ribbonku wuxuu kugu qasbayaa inaad gujiso tab ilaa tab si aad u hesho waxaad rabto. Isbarbardhigga xarfaha laftooda, haddii aan eegno noocyadii ugu dambeeyay ee Windows, uma eka sida hufnaanta interface ribbon uu wax badan ka beddelay Windows 10 tan iyo Windows 8.1 . Haddana arrimuhu way sii fiicnaan karaan kuwa soo socda Windows 10 Cusboonaysiinta abuurayaasha^{(Creators Update)} .

Comparison: Is the Windows ribbon interface more efficient than the old-school menus?

When we talked with others about the new versions of Windows, we unwillingly started a debate abоut thе ribbon and іts efficiency. Sоme people do not like thе fact that Windows 10 and Windows 8.1 use it more widely than Windows 7, and there are still people who complain that it is way less efficient compared to the older interface from Windows XP. In order to рut an end to this debatе using facts instead of subjective oрinions, we decided to create a benchmark of sorts. A series of measurements that cаn be used to compare the efficiency of the ribbon interface, as it is used in Windows 10 vs. Windows 8.1 vs. Windows 7 vs. the interface from the old Windows XP. Here arе the results:

The testing procedure

We created four virtual machines: one with Windows 10, one with Windows 8.1, one with Windows 7, and one with Windows XP Service Pack 3. All the operating systems had all the latest updates installed. We tested three applications that are present in all these operating systems, and which all use the ribbon: WordPad, Paint and Windows/File Explorer.

Then, we enabled all the toolbars and buttons that can be found in these applications. For example, we enabled all the buttons in the Quick Access Toolbar found in the apps from Windows 10, Windows 8.1 and Windows 7. In Windows XP, we enabled all the toolbars in Windows Explorer. All these buttons and toolbars were enabled using the default menus and settings. We did NOT run any registry hacks or third party tools to enable additional features.

Then, we wrote down what we think are the most common tasks you are likely to execute in these three applications (WordPad, Paint and File Explorer), in Windows 10, Windows 8.1, Windows 7 and Windows XP. We measured the number of steps required to complete these tasks and compared the results. Any task that could not be executed in all the operating systems, was excluded from measurements. For example, in Windows XP, you cannot insert a URL website address as a link to a text selection in WordPad, and Redo does not exist as a feature in Windows Explorer.

We wanted to make a click-based comparison so we did not use any keyboard shortcuts to speed up any of the tasks. Everything was done using the mouse, the menus, and buttons available in each application. The keyboard was not used unless it was required to make a mandatory text entry to complete a task (e.g. renaming a file or folder).

The ribbon user interface in WordPad - Up to 21% more efficient

The first application we analyzed was WordPad - the default document editor included in all Windows versions and editions.

We analyzed a series of 12 common tasks people execute when working with a document in WordPad. Although the results were surprisingly similar for most tasks performed in Windows 10, Windows 8.1 or Windows 7, things changed significantly compared to Windows XP. "Copy & paste special", inserting pictures, and saving documents are all tasks you'll do a lot faster if you use modern Windows operating systems.

All in all, we believe it is fair to say that the ribbon in Windows 10 brings an efficiency improvement of up to 21% when compared to Windows XP, but it's only 3% faster than the ribbon interface in Windows 8.1. The following chart should offer you a clearer picture.

The ribbon user interface in Paint - Up to 42% more efficient

Let's go to Paint - the tool which is very likely to be the world's most basic yet most used graphic painting program. We tested a set of 16 tasks in this application.

Here, the improvements that the ribbon user interface brought in Windows 7, Windows 8.1 and Windows 10 are obvious when compared to the old Windows XP.

Surprisingly, it also looks like nothing has changed since Windows 7, as the results we got in the measurements were exactly the same in the more recent versions of Windows. But, hopefully, the user interface from Paint will become even more efficient in the soon to come Windows 10 Creators Update.

In Paint, the ribbon interface is up to 42% more efficient in Windows 10, Windows 8.1 and Windows 7, versus the old menus that were used in Windows XP.

The ribbon user interface in Windows/File Explorer - Up to 55% more efficient

Last, but not least, we tested Windows/File Explorer, which is the most used application of all the three we looked at.

We compared a number of 15 tasks which we believe are executed pretty often by people using this tool.

In Windows/File Explorer we noticed the biggest improvement of all tools. The File Explorer in Windows 10 and Windows 8.1 is 43% more efficient than that from Windows XP. Not only does the ribbon give the user quicker access to various options, but it also includes new options and is better organized in each new Windows version. However, we found no improvements in the File Explorer from Windows 10, compared to the File Explorer in Windows 8.1.

Conclusion

Personally, we did not expect to see big improvements in usability between the different versions of the ribbon interface. But, we believe that the results speak for themselves. The ribbon in Windows 8.1 and Windows 10 does give faster access to the actions and controls available in each application we tested, compared to the user interface you'll find in Windows 7. On the other hand, people who use the old style interface often customize the menus so that all common activities are available with one click. The ribbon forces you to click from tab to tab to get to what you want. Comparing the ribbons themselves, if we take a look at the latest versions of Windows, it doesn't seem like the efficiency of the ribbon interface has changed much in Windows 10 since Windows 8.1. Yet things could improve further in the next Windows 10 Creators Update.

Related posts

• 12 shay oo yaryar oo Windows 10 ka fiican noocyadii hore -

• 13-ka wax ee ugu wanaagsan Windows 10

• Tilmaamaha ugu fiican ee Windows 11: 8 waxyaabood oo waaweyn oo ku saabsan -

• Su'aalo fudud: Waa maxay Microsoft Office 365?

• Falanqaynta: Rakibaadda abka desktop-ka ee degdega ah waxay burburisaa waxqabadka kombayutarka!

• Astaamohee ka yimid Windows 7 ayaan hadda laga heli karin Windows 10? -

• Soo deji ururinta ugu weyn ee miisaska Windows-ka gaaban ee bilaashka ah!

• Sida Google Drive loogu daro File Explorer -

• Sida loo beddelo qaab-dhismeedka galka gudaha Windows 10's File Explorer

• Waa maxay View Task in Windows 10 iyo sida loo isticmaalo

• Sida loo isticmaalo aragtida File Explorer gudaha Windows 10 sida pro -

• 10ka goobood ee ugu wanaagsan ee lagu soo dejisan karo xarfaha bilaashka ah

• Sida loogu kala beddelo CMD iyo PowerShell gudaha Terminalka Windows

• Sida loo sameeyo Google mashiinka raadinta ee Microsoft Edge -

• Waa maxay far iyo waa maxay qoyska fartu? -

• Sida loo isticmaalo Windows USB/DVD Download Tool

• Sida loo helo, loo habeeyo, oo meesha looga saaro kordhinta Microsoft Edge -

• Sida loo isticmaalo Windows 10 Taleefankaaga App-ka ee wata Android-ka casriga ah

• Sida loo isticmaalo Search gudaha Windows 11 -

• 5 siyaabood oo aad laba-gujiso adigoo hal gujin gudaha Windows