Matoorka Raadinta Keebaa Soo Celiya Natiijooyinka ugu naxdinta badan?

Intarneedku waxa uu ina siinayaa helitaan xog aan xadidnayn oo ku dhow. Laakin, intee la aamini karaa xogtaas? Fikradaha shirqoolka iyo macluumaadka khaldan ayaa ku baahsan intarneedka. Waxyaabaha muranka dhaliyay(Controversial) iyo xitaa khatarta ah ma adka in la helo. 

Sababtaas awgeed, waxaan rabnay inaan ogaano makiinadaha raadinta u adeegaya macluumaadka ugu walaacsan. Waxaan diirada saarnay raadintayada qaybaha soo socda:

naag oo ka naxsan waxa ay ku aragto kombayutarkeeda

  • Khilaafaadka(Controversies) : Wax kasta oo loo arko inay yihiin kala qaybsanaan, ay ku jiraan tallaalka Covid-19 , aragtida jinsiyadeed ee muhiimka ah, iyo doorashada 2020.
  • Shirqoolo(Conspiracies) : Aragtiyaha sheegta dhacdo ama xaalad xaaladeed ayaa ka dhalata shirqoollo sir ah oo ay wadaan shaqsiyaad ama kooxo awood leh. Tusaale ahaan, aragtida shirqoolka ee ah in dayaxu soo degay ay ahayd been abuur.
  • Ujeedada khatarta ah(Dangerous intent) : Wax kasta oo u horseedaya xaalad khatar ah, sida samaynta bambooyinka kariyaha cadaadiska ama sida loo daabaco qori 3D ah.

Kadibna mid walba oo natiijada ka mid ah ayaanu falanqaynay si aanu u kala saarno afar qaybood oo waaweyn. Qaybahaasi waa:

  • Macluumaad khaldan ama xog la dareemo:(Misinformation or sensationalized information:) Xog aan run ahayn, macluumaad khaldan, ama xog qalloocan oo loo soo bandhigay xaqiiqo si loo helo xiiso.
  • Pro-conspiracy : Taageerida aragtida shirqoolka ama soo bandhigida aragti cusub oo shirqool ah.
  • Aan dhaliil lahayn: si(Uncritical:) ula kac ah oo dhexdhexaad ah. Aan taageero u fidin fikrad laga yaabo in laga naxo, laakiin aan laga hadlin, sidoo kale. 
  • Waxyeelo leh(Harmful) : Si firfircoon ugu hagida akhristayaasha xaaladaha khatarta ah, sida is-dilitaanka.

Waxaan falanqeynay 2,640 natiijadood oo ka yimid afar makiinadood - Google , Yahoo , Bing , iyo DuckDuckGo - si aan u ogaano midka soo baxay macluumaadka ugu badan. 

Google waxa uu bixiyay Natiijooyinka(Fewest Alarming Results) Digniinaha ugu yar iyo DuckDuckGo ayaa la keenay inta ugu badan

Daraasadani waxay heshay farqi cad oo u dhexeeya afarta matoorada ee waaweyn. Gaar ahaan sida ay u maamulaan natiijooyinka raadinta khatarta ah ama cabsida leh. Waxaan u aragnaa natiijooyinka khatarta ah kuwa leh ujeedo khatar ah, kor u qaada macluumaadka khaldan, ama kicinaya aragtiyaha shirqoolka. 

Kaliya 3% natiijooyinka raadinta Google(Google’s search results) ayaa halis ahaa - kuwa ugu yar afartan matoorada raadinta, ilaa hadda. Waxa ku xigtay (Next)Yahoo , oo leh 1 ka mid ah 4 natiijooyinka taasoo horseedaysa ilo taban ama khatar ah. DuckDuckGo iyo Bing waxay u badnaayeen inay keenaan natiijooyin khatar ah. Ku dhawaad ​​​​saddex meelood meel natiijadii Bing iyo DuckDuckGo waxay ahaayeen kuwo xun ama naxdin leh. Tani waxay macno samaynaysaa maadaama DuckDuckGo ay natiijooyin badan ka(pulls a lot of its results) soo saartay tusmada Bing. 

makiinadaha raadinta ee soo celiya natiijooyin naxdin leh

Soo bandhigida macluumaadka khatarta ah ayaa sagaal jeer uga dhow DuckDuckGo iyo Bing marka loo eego Google . Isticmaalayaasha Yahoo ayaa todobo jeer uga dhowaatay isticmaalayaasha Google inay la kulmaan natiijooyin khatar ah. Natiijooyinkani waxay muujinayaan sida ay suurtogal u tahay in qofku la kulmo macluumaadka khatarta ah ee internetka. 

Matoorada Raadinta(Search) oo leh Natiijooyinka ugu dareenka badan(Most Sensationalized Results)

Marka xigta, waxaan u falanqeynay natiijooyinka raadinta mowduucyo muran dhaliyay ama dareen leh. Kuwaas waxaa ka mid ahaa COVID-19 , isbedelka cimilada, iyo caafimaadka dhimirka ee Madaxweyne Biden. 

Markaad ka raadinaysay " caafimaadka dhimirka ee Biden " DuckDuckGo , natiijadii ugu sareysay waxay ahayd " FLASHBACK : Dhakhtarka Qaliinka Maskaxda ayaa u sheegay Biden(Brain Surgeon Told Biden) inuu haysto wax ka yar 50% fursada(Chance) ah inuu noqdo mid caadi ah." Ciwaanku wuxuu soo jeedinayaa in Biden uu leeyahay arrin caafimaad, laakiin waxa ku jira waxa loola jeedaa qalliinka laba aneurysms ee dabayaaqadii 1980-yadii. 

Dhab ahaantii, marka ay timaado mawduucyada muranka dhaliyay:

  • 27% of DuckDuckGo results waxaa loo kala saaray macluumaad khaldan ama dareen dareen leh.
  • 25% of Bing results waxaa loo kala saaray macluumaad khaldan ama dareen dareen leh.
  • 18% of Yahoo results waxaa loo kala saaray xog khaldan ama dareen dareen leh.
  • 2% of Google results loo kala saaray xog khaldan ama dareen dareen

" Isbeddelka(Climate) cimiladu waa been abuur" waxay soo celisay natiijooyinka ugu dareenka badan DuckDuckGo , Bing , iyo Yahoo . Google kaliya waxay soo celisay laba natiijadood oo dareen leh oo ah 150kii aanu ku qiimaynay qaybtan.

makiinadaha raadinta oo leh natiijooyin dareen leh

"Kaniiniga Cas" ayaa sidoo kale caan ku ahaa natiijooyinka raadinta. Laakiin, makiinad kasta oo wax raadisa marka laga reebo Google ma ahayn mid dhaleecayn ah. Erayga laftiisu waa muran, oo ka yimid muuqaal Matrix caan ah. Marka qof qaato "kiniiniga cas," waxay diyaar u yihiin inay bartaan run aan dejin karin ama nolosha beddeli karta. Maanta, ereyga waxaa inta badan isticmaala(often used) kuwa xaqa u janjeera, sida Donald Trump iyo taageerayaasha Alex Jones

Natiijooyin badan ayaa soo bandhigay fariimo khaldan ama kuwo kale oo waxyeelo leh. Google dib uguma soo celinayso kaniiniga casaanka(Red Pill) ah ama fariinta mugdiga ah ee ereyga 30ka natiijadood ee ugu horeeya. Dhab ahaantii, natiijadii ugu horreysay ee Google waa maqaal la yiraahdo "Liqitaanka Kaniiniga Cas(Red Pill) : Safarka wadnaha ee misogyny casriga ah."

Matoorada Raadinta ee bixiya macluumaadka(Search Engines That Provide Information) ulajeedka khatarta ah(Dangerous Intent)

Si loo daraaseeyo natiijooyinka leh ujeedo khatar ah, waxaan diiradda saarnay weydiimaha ku xeeran qoryaha, bambooyinka, daroogooyinka, iyo ismiidaaminta.

Marka la barbardhigo isticmaalayaasha Google , DuckDuckGo iyo isticmaalayaasha Bing waxay afar jeer uga dhow yihiin inay la kulmaan natiijooyin leh ujeedo khatar ah. Isticmaalayaasha Yahoo waxay 3.6 jeer uga dhow yihiin isticmaalayaasha Google . Iyadoo taas la yiri, dhammaan goobaha raadinta waxay soo celiyeen natiijooyin waxtar leh oo loogu talagalay weydiimaha khatarta ah. 

Saddex mawduuc oo waaweyn ayaa soo celiyay natiijooyinka ugu khatarta badan. Dhammaan afarta matoorada raadinta, ereyada soo socdaa waxay keeneen macluumaadka ugu khatarta badan:

  • Sida loo daabaco qoriga 3D.
  • Sida loo sameeyo meth.
  • Hababka isdilka.

On Google , Bing , iyo Yahoo , " Sida(How) loo daabaco qoriga 3D" ayaa soo celiyay natiijooyin badan iyadoo ujeedo khatar ah leh. DuckDuckGo ,(DuckDuckGo) "Sida loo sameeyo meth" waxay bixisay natiijooyin khatar badan. 

makiinadaha raadinta oo leh natiijooyin khatar ah

Dhammaan afarta goobood waxay kaloo soo celiyeen natiijooyin waxtar leh oo ku saabsan is-dilid. Laakiin waxaa xiiso leh in la ogaado farqiga u dhexeeya Google , Bing , iyo Yahoo vs. DuckDuckGo .

Markaad raadinayso "habka ugu fudud ee isdilka" iyo "sida ugu xanuunka yar ee isdilka, " Google , Bing , iyo Yahoo waxay leeyihiin farriimo waxtar leh oo weyn oo ay weheliyaan nambarka Qaranka ee Kahortagga Is-dilka Lifeline(National Suicide Prevention Lifeline) . Waxaa loola jeedaa in lagu soo jiito dareenka isticmaalaha ka hor inta aysan furin natiijada raadinta. 

DuckDuckGo , "sida loo is-dilo" waxay soo jiidataa(DuckDuckGo) agabka ka hortagga is-miidaaminta si kor loogu qaado natiijooyinka raadinta. Laakiin, agabyadani ma muuqdaan marka la raadinayo "hababka ugu fudud ama ugu xanuunka yar ee isdilka." Dhab ahaantii, natiijada ugu horreysa ee su'aasha "ugu fudud" xitaa waxay soo jeedinaysaa kaniiniyada hurdada ee sharaxaadda meta, inkastoo boostada lafteeda ay ku jirto macluumaadka lagu joojinayo is-dilitaanka.

Sida daraasaddan muujisay, natiijooyinka raadinta DuckDuckGo waxay u muuqdaan inay yihiin kuwa ugu yar ee la sifeeyo ama la baaro.

Matoorada Raadinta(Search) ee Saaxiibtinimada leh ee ugu badan

Matoorada raadinta(Search) lama sinna nooca waxyaabaha ku jira shirqoolka ee ka dhigaya. Dadka Maraykanka badankoodu (Americans) waxay aaminsan yihiin ugu yaraan hal shirqool(believe in at least one conspiracy) . Laakin maadaama intarneetku uu ka dhigay isku xidhka dadka kale mid la heli karo si ka badan sidii hore, shirqoolada ayaa u faafay si ka dhakhso badan sidii hore.

DuckDuckGo waa mashiinka raadinta saaxiibtinimo ee ugu shirqoolka badan. Oo ay la socdaan Bing iyo Yahoo , aaladahaan waxay ogolaadeen ilo-wax-u-akhris-shirqool gudaha saddexda bog ee ugu horreeya natiijooyinka. Waxaa muhiim ah in la ogaado in ilo-wareedka iyo wararka wararka ay ka badnaayeen boggaga shirqoolka ee saddexda bog ee hore. 

Weydiimaha ka dhasha aragtiyaha shirqoolka

DuckDuckGo , (DuckDuckGo)Bing , iyo Yahoo , shirqoollada ugu caansan ee soo celiyay ilaha dhaqaale ee shirqoolka ayaa ahaa "Waxaa la dilay Jeffrey Epstein" iyo "9/11 gudaha shaqada. "DuckDuckGo iyo Bing waxay sidoo kale lahaayeen natiijooyin badan oo shirqool ah oo u soo baxay "Sandy Hook hoax."

Guud ahaan, Yahoo boggiisa ugu horreeya waxay ahaayeen kuwo aad u yar marka loo eego natiijooyinka shirqoolka marka loo eego DuckDuckGo ama Bing

On Google , kaliya laba erey oo shirqool oo muhiim ah ayaa soo celinaya agab kasta oo taageeraya: 9/11 iyo soo degista dayaxa. Dhammaan aragtiyaha kale ee shirqoolka waxay soo celiyeen agab xirfadeed iyo cilmiyeed kuwaas oo burinaya aragtiyaha shirqoolka. 

Waa kuwee mareegaha ugu badan?

Matoorada raadinta(Search) waa qayb ka mid ah isla'egta soo celinta macluumaadka. Mareegaha gaarka ah ee u soo noqda weydiimo kasta waxay saameeyaan gudbinta khilaafaadka, shirqoolada, iyo shuruudaha ujeeddooyinka khatarta ah. Sababtan awgeed, waxaan rabnay inaan si wanaagsan u fahanno noocyada shabakadaha in goob kasta oo goob raadin ay siiso isticmaaleyaasheeda.

On Google , Bing , iyo DuckDuckGo , Wikipedia waa degelka loogu adeego badan yahay. On Yahoo , Dhexdhexaad(Medium) , madal blogging, waa goobta loogu adeego badan. Waxa xiiso leh(Interestingly) , dhammaan afarta matoorada raadinta waxay u adeegaan YouTube in ka badan hal wareed kasta.

sawirka Wikipedia, astaanta dhexe iyo Youtube

Dhammaan natiijooyinka raadinta, in ka badan 10% Google 's waxay ka yimaadeen xarumaha hay'adaha, sida .gov iyo .edu . DuckDuckGo waxay soo celisay 36% natiijooyin hay'ad ka yar marka loo eego Google , Bingna(Bing) wuxuu soo celiyay 35% wax ka yar. Yahoo waxay soo celisay 19% ka yar natiijooyinka hay'adaha.

Google ayaa sidoo kale u adeegay natiijooyinka ugu yar ee warbaahinta bulshada, sida goobaha sida Reddit ama Dhexdhexaad(Medium) . DuckDuckGo waxay u adeegtay 54% natiijooyin ka badan warbaahinta bulshada marka loo eego Google . Bing ayaa soo celiyay 42% in ka badan, Yahoo -na waxa ay soo celisay 27% natiijooyin baraha bulshada ah. 

Faafinta wararka been abuurka ah iyo hadalada waxyeelada leh ayaa sii fiday tobankii sano ee la soo dhaafay. Iyo sida matoorada raadinta kala duwan ay u soo baxeen sida goobaha waaweyn, waxaa jira farqi muuqda oo u dhexeeya natiijooyinka raadinta. 

DuckDuckGo waxay aad ugu dhowdahay inay soo celiso natiijooyinka dhibaatada leh. Kuwaas waxaa ka mid noqon kara boggaga internetka ee aragtida shirqoolka shirqoolka ama goobaha leh ujeedo khatar ah. Natiijooyinkan la midka ah waxay ku dhowaayeen inay u badan tahay Bing .

Yahoo waxay u egtahay inay ka xaddidan tahay DuckDuckGo iyo Bing . Guud ahaan waxay soo celisaa ilo yar oo khatar ah iyo goobaha macluumaadka khaldan. Si kastaba ha ahaatee, Google ayaa shaandheysa natiijooyin ka khatarsan iyo macluumaad khaldan marka loo eego goobaha kale ee raadinta.   

Logos ee duckduckgo, yahoo, google iyo bing

Internetku waa mid ka mid ah aaladaha ugu weyn ee bini'aadmigu leeyahay. Waxay noo ogolaataa inaan baadho ku dhawaad ​​mawduuc kasta, laakiin hantida macluumaadka kuma koobna nuxurka dhib la'aanta ah. 

Talooyin badan oo kombuyuutar ah ayaa xooga saaraya muhiimada software-ka ka hortaga iyo isticmaalka furaha sirta ah ee adag, laakiin ka fogaanshaha macluumaadka khaldan iyo waxyaabaha waxyeelada leh ee internetka ayaa sidoo kale muhiim ah. U dooro mashiinka raadinta si caqli leh. Had iyo jeer iska ilaali natiijooyinka raadinta khatarta ah.   

Habka(Methodology)

Intii u dhaxaysay Maarso 25 iyo Maarso 29, 2022, waxaan ku falanqeynay 2,640 natiijooyin raadin afar goobood oo waaweyn si loo go'aamiyo midka soo celiya natiijooyinka ugu khatarta badan: Google, Bing, Yahoo, iyo DuckDuckGo. (Between March 25 and March 29, 2022, we analyzed 2,640 search results across four major search engines to determine which one returns the most dangerous results: Google, Bing, Yahoo, and DuckDuckGo. )

In order to do so, we created a list of topics that fall under controversies, conspiracies, and dangerous intent. We then analyzed the first 30 results for related queries. Those queries are: Biden’s mental health, is the war in Ukraine justified, critical race theory in schools, gender identity in schools, was Jeffrey Epstein murdered, is the covid vaccine safe, does the covid vaccine change your DNA, does ivermectin work, red pill, how to 3D print a gun, how to make a pressure cooker bomb, how to make meth, did we really land on the moon, Sandy Hook hoax, 9/11 inside job, who is Q, flat earth theory, least painful way to commit suicide, easiest way to commit suicide, did Trump win the election, proof of 2020 election voter fraud, climate change, is climate change real, and climate change hoax.



About the author

Waxaan ahay injineer software leh in ka badan 10 sano oo waayo-aragnimo ah warshadaha software. Waxaan ku takhasusay abuurista iyo ilaalinta codsiyada software shaqsi iyo shirkad, iyo sidoo kale horumarinta qalabka horumarinta ee ganacsiyada yaryar iyo ururada waaweyn. Xirfadahaygu waxay ku jiraan horumarinta codeBase adag, wax ka saarista & qalabka tijaabinta, iyo inaan si dhow ula shaqeeyo isticmaalayaasha dhamaadka si loo hubiyo in codsiyadoodu u shaqeeyaan si aan cillad lahayn.



Related posts